Ely's & Co. Waterproof Changing Pad Cover / Cradle Sheet 2-Pack - 100% Cotton Jersey Knit - Grey Stars Review (2026)

One cover, two jobs

The core idea behind this set is dual use: the same cover fits a changing pad and, per the listing, doubles as a cradle sheet, which matters most in small nurseries or shared rooms where buying separate changing pad covers and bassinet sheets is not practical. The grey stars print keeps the look gender neutral, so it works whether you already know the baby's sex or not, and it will not clash with a nursery you are furnishing on a budget. Getting two pieces of nursery textile use out of one purchase is the main value proposition here, rather than a single-purpose product that only fits one piece of furniture.

Materials: cotton jersey with a waterproof layer

The cover combines a 100 percent cotton jersey knit face, the same soft, stretchy knit used in many baby sheet sets, with a waterproof lining underneath to stop leaks and spills from reaching the pad itself. That waterproof layer is the main functional difference from a plain jersey cover, and it is what lets the product be marketed for both diaper changes and overnight cradle use. The trade-off with any waterproof-backed fabric is reduced breathability compared to plain cotton, since the lining that blocks moisture from passing through also limits airflow, which is worth knowing if your nursery runs warm or you use it as a cradle sheet in summer.

Sizing and fit on different pads

Because this cover is marketed as dual-purpose for both changing pads and cradle mattresses, the elastic edge needs to accommodate a range of pad thicknesses and sizes rather than being cut for one exact product. That flexibility is convenient if you own a nonstandard or compact changing pad common in small apartment nurseries, but it also means the fit can run looser on a very thin or narrow pad than a cover sized for one specific product line. If your changing pad or cradle mattress is an unusual shape, it is worth checking your own pad's dimensions against the cover before assuming a snug, wrinkle-free fit.

Washing and everyday durability

The set is machine washable, which is essential for a changing pad cover that will see regular spills and blowouts, and the two-cover pack means you always have a backup while one is in the laundry. Cotton jersey with a bonded waterproof layer generally holds up well to repeated washing, though following a gentle cycle and avoiding high heat when drying helps the waterproof backing last longer without cracking or peeling, a common failure point for budget waterproof linings over many wash cycles. Buyers who plan to use this daily for a year or more should expect the waterproof layer's performance to be the first thing to watch for wear.

Value for small nurseries

For a small-space nursery that cannot dedicate real estate to separate changing pad covers and cradle sheets, this 2-pack earns its keep by doing both jobs in a neutral print that will not need replacing if a second child arrives. It sits in the mid-range for changing pad covers rather than the cheapest option, reflecting the added waterproof lining and dual-use design. Parents who only need a changing pad cover and already own dedicated cradle sheets may find single-purpose covers a slightly better value, but for anyone consolidating nursery textiles into fewer pieces, the flexibility here is a real advantage.

Frequently asked questions